Evening sunburst in mountains

How high ethical standards can drive the ESG agenda for Irish businesses

The need of the hour is to build processes and controls that can turn ESG programmes into long-term value creators.


In brief

  • Independent corroboration can turn strong ESG performance into a long-term value creator.
  • Organisations that exaggerate their ESG credentials are exposed to reputational damage.
  • Society expects business to report on all of its impacts.

Environment, social and governance (ESG) reporting has become increasingly important for businesses in recent years. Customers, investors, financiers, and society at large now expect companies to report on the non-financial aspects of their operations in much more formal ways. That pressure can be harnessed to energise an organisation’s integrity agenda.

ESG reporting goes beyond the Corporate and Social Responsibility (CSR) reports which most people are familiar with. People now want to know how the core business of the organisation impacts the planet and its people. They also want details of the impacts of non-core aspects, downstream and upstream, across the entire supply and value chains.

The environment is providing the impetus for the establishment of recognised frameworks and standards such as the Global Reporting Initiative of the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board or the newly established International Sustainability Standards Board.

“Our Climate Change and Sustainability Services team has seen a marked increase in the demand for independent verification of ESG reports,” says Derarca Dennis, EY Ireland Assurance Partner. “We expect this will become the norm in the near-term along with harmonisation of sustainability accounting standards,” she added.

The EY Global Integrity Report shows that “greenwashing,¹” however artfully delivered, is increasingly ineffective at convincing ever more sceptical employees, customers, and other stakeholders of an organisation’s supposedly superior ESG credentials.

Company statements and ethical standards are coming under increased scrutiny, with the social and governance aspects of ESG becoming just as important as the environmental component. Organisations that do not adhere to high standards of ethics and integrity will score poorly on ESG overall.

Irish organisations are increasingly aware of the challenges and opportunities presented by the ESG agenda. Some 71% of respondents to the EY Ireland State of Sustainability Report 2021 rated the level of leadership understanding of sustainability within their organisation as either good or comprehensive, while 61% said there was good or complete awareness of sustainability considerations and implications across their organisations. However, the Irish data for the Integrity  Report shows that only 30% of companies surveyed have a policy on either Corporate Social Responsibility or ESG.

Companies shown to have a gap between their claims and their performance run the risk of suffering severe reputational damage. Against this backdrop, it is no longer sufficient to claim to care about corporate integrity and ESG performance, organisations must act. They must both have an operational framework and harness the power of their own data to develop ways to measure their own integrity culture and build the processes and controls that can turn ESG programmes into long-term value creators. In doing so, organisations should seek data that aligns with their own corporate integrity agenda.

That high level of awareness among Irish organisations is very welcome. It is now time to build on that and translate it into concrete actions which will see organisations embrace the latest reporting standards and turn ESG and integrity into mutually supportive agendas.

The increased societal expectations of businesses to act ethically extend to the behaviour of corporate leaders. 68% of respondents to the most recent Edelman Trust Barometer expect CEOs to fix societal problems which haven’t been addressed by governments, while 65% believe CEOs should be as accountable to the public as they are to shareholders².


Summary

Purpose-led Irish organisations are aware of the close interrelationship between ESG and integrity, and the need to build a culture of transparency, good governance, and trust. ESG reporting goes beyond the Corporate and Social Responsibility (CSR) reports into the larger realm of organisation supply and value chains. Valuation of both ESG risks and opportunities is need of the hour.

About this article

Read more

How Ireland can power ahead with AI-enabled automation

Intelligent automation is a key driver of transformation. Find out how Irish organisations can add AI as a tool to accelerate their hyperautomation journey.

How organisations can adopt an AI model that benefits all

There needs to be a balance between enhancing business’ societal license to operate and the financial Return on Investment from AI. Find out how it can be done.