A finger pointing to maximum point in a graph on a digital screen

Fiscal consolidation in India: charting a credible glide path

EY
EY India

Multidisciplinary professional services organization

5 minute read 24 Mar 2023
Related topics
Tax
Tax controversy

A reduced fiscal deficit will help India make more investable resources available for the private sector. 

In brief

  • Introduced in 2003, the Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management Act (FRBMA) aims to keep fiscal deficit under check.
  • India’s fiscal deficit to GDP ratio peaked during pandemic.
  • The government is persistently working towards reducing fiscal deficit, as seen in Budget 2023 as well. 

Fiscal consolidation so far: success and failures

The Government of India in 2003 enacted the Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management Act (FRBMA), which focused on reducing the fiscal deficit of the country. However, it was only in FY08 when the fiscal deficit was brought below 3%. States, who enacted their individual Fiscal Responsibility Legislations (FRLs) from 2002 to 2010 considered together, were more successful in keeping their fiscal deficit below 3% in many years.

fiscal deficit relative to gdp union government

Bringing union government’s revenue account in balance or surplus was also the part of the 2003 FRBMA and was hence, endorsed by the Twelfth Finance Commission. It became a feature of states’ FRLs. However, in the 2018 amendment to the union government’s FRBMA, revenue account balance as an objective was given up. The amended Act specified the debt-GDP targets for the union government, states and their combined accounts at 40%, 20% and 60% respectively while the fiscal deficit to GDP targets were kept at 3% each for the union government and aggregate of states.  

COVID-19-induced slippages

Chart 2 shows the profiles of the debt-GDP ratio of the central and state governments and on their combined account. The combined debt-GDP ratio had peaked in FY04 at 85.5%. It fell to 67.8% in FY15 after which it increased progressively to 75.9% by FY20. 

debt to gdp ratio union government states and combined

With the onset of COVID-19 in FY21, India experienced a negative growth of (-)5.7% as per NSO’s second advance estimates. Even the nominal growth in this year was negative at (-)1.2%. This resulted in a major deterioration in the debt-GDP ratios across the board. The consolidated debt-GDP ratio increased sharply to close to 90% with union government’s debt-GDP ratio (excluding any on-lending to states with external debt estimated at the current market exchange rate) at 58.7% and that of states at 31%. The combined debt-GDP ratio exceeded the benchmark by nearly 30% points. Union government’s fiscal deficit to GDP ratio in the COVID-19 year peaked at 9.2%, well in excess of the operational target of 3%. 

Union government’s FY24 Budget: charting a credible glide path

The union budgets post FY21, with positive growth rates and some effort at fiscal consolidation, resulted in a fall in the union government’s fiscal deficit to GDP ratio to 6.8% and 6.5% in FY22 and FY23, respectively. This effort was strengthened in the FY24 budget, where in spite of global economic headwinds, central government persisted with fiscal consolidation. Compared to a reduction of 0.3% points in FY23, the budgeted reduction in the fiscal deficit-GDP ratio in FY24 is 0.5% points, which according to present indications is further to be accelerated to an annual reduction of 0.7% points in the next two years, enabling a fiscal deficit level of 4.5% of GDP by FY26 (Table 1). In FY24 budget, the union government is focused on capital expenditure growth (37.4%) while limiting revenue expenditure growth to 1.2% with a view to taking advantage of the high capital expenditure multiplier. According to RBI (2019), union government’s capital expenditure peak multiplier was estimated at 3.25 while that of revenue expenditure is 0.45. 

union goverments debt and fiscal deficit relative to gdp

How EY can help

  • Tax policy

    Our tax policy professionals can help you stay ahead of potential tax changes, better manage tax risk and understand key tax trends. Find out more.

    Read more

Government borrowing is a pre-emptive claim on the economy’s available investible resources. In India, it is only the household sector which has an investible surplus in the form of financial savings which presently amount to 8% of GDP. Supplementing this by a net capital inflow from abroad of nearly 2.5% of GDP, total investible resources add to 10.5% of GDP. In FY24, the combined fiscal deficit of central and state governments may amount to 9.4% of GDP, leaving limited scope for borrowing by the private sector and the PSUs. As combined fiscal deficit is brought down, progressively more investible resources would become available for the private sector. In the years after FY26, union government’s fiscal deficit may be allowed to fall by higher margins of say 0.75% points of GDP per year with a view to reaching the FRBM target in the next two years.

 

By FY28, a fiscal deficit-GDP ratio of 3% would be reached, but according to our estimates, assuming a nominal growth of 11%, the debt-GDP ratio would be close to 50%, 10% points above the FRBM target. Continuing with an 11% nominal growth and retaining a fiscal deficit-GDP level of 3%, the debt-GDP ratio is expected to reach 40% by FY35. As government debt as a proportion of GDP falls, the effective interest rate on government debt would also fall, reducing the interest payment to revenue receipts ratio, thereby facilitating the accelerated pace of reduction in fiscal deficit for reaching the desired target. If the implicit price deflator-based inflation is kept at 4%, a real GDP growth of 6.7% would be required over this period. Sustaining a growth rate at this level would require a suitable growth in private investment. It is only achieving the FRBM norms and adherence to these over a long period that would leave enough investible resources for the private sector to contribute to growth. 

     

This article is co-authored by C.Rangarajan, Former Chairman, Prime Minister’s Economic Advisory Council and Former Governor, Reserve Bank of India, and D.K.Srivastava, Chief Policy Advisor, EY India and Former Director, Madras School of Economics.  

Download the full pdf

PDF (3 MB)

Summary

The 2003 FRBMA was introduced by the union government to ensure financial discipline across the country. In FY23, the country saw a reduction in fiscal deficit by 0.3% points. Considering this, India still has a long way to go and it is important for her to adhere to fiscal discipline over a long period of time to ensure sustained economic growth in the years to come. 

About this article

EY
EY India
Multidisciplinary professional services organization
Related topics
Tax
Tax controversy

Related articles

How Budget 2023 has increased the attractiveness for IFSC, GIFT IFSC

Discover how GIFT (IFSC is expected to play a pivotal role in India’s growth journey. Learn more about Tax Incentives for IFSC Unit - GIFT IFSC

EY India

How Budget 2023 changes are likely to impact the e-commerce operators in India

EY highlights how Budget 2023 proposals aim to deal with the taxation in e-commerce. Learn more about the changes impacting e-commerce operators.

Union Budget 2023: strict clauses continue to challenge charitable institutions  

EY highlights the amendment in charitable trust. Learn more about the Charitable trust amendment in budget 2023.

EY India

    EY refers to the global organization, and may refer to one or more, of the member firms of Ernst & Young Global Limited, each of which is a separate legal entity. Ernst & Young Global Limited, a UK company limited by guarantee, does not provide services to clients.