Challenges in decarbonizing steel production
The report identifies several hurdles in transitioning to green steel production:
- High cost of green hydrogen: Green hydrogen, essential for decarbonizing steel production, remains expensive at $4–$7 per kilogram, compared to $1.8 for grey hydrogen.
- Limited scrap availability: India's scrap market is underdeveloped, complicating the adoption of Electric Arc Furnaces (EAF), which rely on scrap for lower emissions.
- Demand for green steel: India’s price sensitive market unwilling to pay the premium associated with green steel, without specific legislative support
- Inadequate carbon capture technology: While Carbon Capture Utilization and Storage (CCUS) can mitigate emissions, the technology is costly, energy-intensive, and lacks storage infrastructure.
Despite these challenges, the report underscores that collaborative efforts between the government and industry players can help India achieve net-zero emissions by 2070.
Decarbonization pathways for India
The transition to green steel will require a multi-faceted approach. Key decarbonization technologies include:
- Electric Arc Furnaces (EAF): Shifting from BF-BOF to EAF powered by renewable energy can reduce emissions significantly, with further reductions possible through the use of scrap.
- Alternate Energy and Fuels: The industry could explore transitioning to green energy and exploring alternate fuels like Biomass for BF.
- Green Hydrogen DRI: Replacing coal with natural gas and subsequently green hydrogen in the DRI process could reduce emissions by up to 97%. However, the high cost and infrastructure demands of green hydrogen limit its immediate adoption.
- Carbon Capture: While not a permanent solution, CCUS can serve as a transitional technology to reduce emissions from existing BF-BOF operations.
- Other new technologies: Several new technologies like Electrowinning, Electric Smelting and Electrolysis are also evolving slowly, and could become viable in future.
Recommendations for accelerating decarbonization
The report outlines several key strategies to accelerate the steel industry transformation in India:
- Promote green hydrogen adoption: Government policies should focus on reducing the cost of green hydrogen through domestic manufacturing and financial incentives.
- Enhance scrap collection and utilization: Expanding the scrappage policy and improving the scrap supply chain will be critical for the widespread adoption of EAF.
- Incentivize green steel: Introducing carbon border tariffs, mandating the use of renewable energy, and providing green financing options such as green bonds can help steelmakers transition to greener processes.