Obligation to charge VAT in case of supply of goods with installation in Slovenia
In the recent months, we have noticed increased issues in regard to correct VAT treatment in cases where the taxable person orders goods, for which the right to dispose as owner is transferred only after the goods are installed or assembled by the foreign supplier or by its subcontractor.
Since the equipment usually represents the majority of the contractual value, and the installations and assembly portray merely the smaller portion, in some cases foreign suppliers report these transactions in their EU Member States as intra-EU supply. In order to ensure that VAT reporting is harmonized, Slovenian entities then report these transaction as intra-EU acquisition of goods. However, such reporting is incorrect and is not in line with VAT legislation.
Namely, Art. 20 of the Slovenian Value Added Act (“VAT Act”) stipulates that the place of supply, when goods are dispatched or transported by the supplier, or by the customer, or by a third person, are installed or assembled by the supplier or another person on his behalf, with or without a trial run, is considered the place where the goods are installed or assembled. Thus, transaction is regarded as a local supply, and not intra-EU supply.
Why is it important for recipients to correctly determine transaction, when in case when a foreign supplier is not identified for VAT purposes, recipient self-charges VAT, as in case of intra-EU acquisitions?
If we leave the differences in VAT reporting aside, a very important difference represents the moment when obligation to charge VAT arises. With local supplies, the obligation to charge VAT arises also in case of prepayments, whereas in case of intra-EU supplies of goods advance payment does not create a tax point.
Due to the high contractual values the payments can be made before the supply is performed, therefore it is very important that the recipients ask themselves whether the payment to the foreign non-VAT registered supplier creates a tax point. Namely, despite of VAT neutrality, taxpayer can face late interest payment due to late self-charge of VAT.
Furthermore, even in the case where the goods are not installed or assembled by the supplier or third party on his behalf, however the goods arrive in Slovenia and the recipient does not acquire the goods upon their arrival in Slovenia but later on, they should ask themselves whether the subsequent purchase on their side can still be regarded as intra-EU acquisition (i.e., can the transport be attributed to the acquisition on their part or whether the storage of the goods “broke” the link between the transport and transfer of right to dispose with goods to recipient) or whether this is local purchase (transport from one Member State to Slovenia is assigned to the movement of supplier’s own goods). In this case correct determination also affects the proper conduct of the recipient in terms of obligation to (self)charge VAT.
In case the supplier is identified for VAT purposes in Slovenia, it will be primarily responsible for correct and timely charging of VAT.