6 minute read 14 Sep 2021
Low angle of telecommunications towers against sky

Why an asset-right strategy is telcos’ path to value in a volatile world

Authors
Tom Loozen

EY Global Telecommunications Leader

Fascinated by the positive impact of telecoms. Passionate musician. Enjoys educating himself on psychology, wine, sports, technology, arts and much more. Husband and father of three daughters.

Adrian Baschnonga

EY Global Technology, Media & Entertainment and Telecommunications (TMT) Lead Analyst

Passionate about digital innovation and inclusion. Inspired by the arts, history and urban spaces.

Barak Ravid

EY-Parthenon Americas Leader

Energized by all things at the intersection of technology and strategy. Passionate about the strength of diverse and inclusive teams. Love sailing, biking, soccer, snowboarding. Father of three girls.

Ulrich Loewer

EY-Parthenon Partner, Technology, Media and Entertainment, and Telecommunications, Ernst & Young LLP

Thought leader in the TMT and Digital Infrastructure sector. Passionate about ubiquitous gigabit connectivity. Trusted for honest and inspiring advice. Proud father of Max and Mia.

6 minute read 14 Sep 2021
Related topics TMT

Telecoms operators need to rethink their asset strategies so they don’t get left behind.

In brief
  • In today’s fast-changing telecoms industry, being asset-light should not always be the target.
  • Re-evaluating what is core versus non-core can help organizations develop an asset-right strategy.

Across many industries, the common mantra until recently has been “asset-light”: transferring capabilities and infrastructure to “better owners” as a way to shift from fixed to variable costs, boost agility and focus on core capabilities.

But in today’s fast-changing telecoms industry, being asset light isn’t enough. What’s needed is a strategy founded on “asset-right”: a holistic approach involving rigorously re-evaluating what’s core and non-core, understanding the interdependencies between different actions around different assets, and aligning the strategic enablers and outcomes.

What’s more, there’s no time to lose in moving to asset-right. As the new wave of asset-centered deals – acquisitions, disposals, carve-outs, joint ventures, collaborative partnerships and more – gains scale and momentum, telecoms operators that fail to rethink their asset strategies will find themselves left trailing and struggling to catch up.

Your platform is burning

Why is going asset-right so critical – and why now? Several forces are converging to put telcos’ asset positions in the spotlight as never before. As industry players ramp up their network investments, sector performance is facing powerful headwinds, with capital intensity rising while leverage is high and getting higher (see Figure 1). And the pressures aren’t going to ease off any time soon, as the 5G and fiber land-grab continues and new deployment models gain ground. 

Infographic European Telecoms: Financial Indicators

At the same time, there are willing buyers and partners in the market for telecoms assets. Non-traditional players such as the tech hyperscalers and private equity investors are buying into or funding telecoms infrastructure. And, across the world, government oversight of – and investment in – telecoms infrastructure is growing, ranging from national 5G strategies to fixed gigabit backbones. For operators themselves, differentiation increasingly hinges upon virtualized and software-defined network architectures.

It all adds up to a burning platform for telcos: a rapidly-evolving environment where there are growing rationales – and opportunities – to acquire and dispose of assets. And where separating infrastructure and services can help telcos release value to fund a new era of product and service innovation.

Taking a holistic view

Hardly surprising, then, that players across the industry are now reappraising their infrastructure positions as a matter of urgency. As they do so, they’re identifying ample opportunities for fresh asset approaches and deals across the ecosystem and all along the telecoms value chain (see Figure 2).

Infographic Asset opportunities across the telecoms ecosystem and value chain

Already, a wide array of participants are acting to unlock value in various parts of the ecosystem. US telcos led the way on divesting datacenters, with European incumbents following suit. Cable providers and tech companies are using mobile virtual network operators (MVNOs) for asset-light entry into consumer mobile. In passive infrastructure, operators are spinning off tower assets alongside TowerCo sale-and-leasebacks; in active infrastructure, network sharing agreements are expanding to 5G cloud cores and rural 4G. And the tech hyperscalers now own or lease more than half of global undersea bandwidth.

These targeted actions are generating value in their own right. But the key to a successful asset-right strategy is to adopt a holistic view across the entire portfolio and landscape, taking account of the linkages and interdependencies between different assets. For example, if you’re an integrated incumbent, what’s your strategy for mobile? Could you divest your passive infrastructure or partner with the hyperscalers? Perhaps more importantly, how would selling off your datacenters affect your 5G and edge cloud strategy?

Aligning the enablers and outcomes

To reach the right answers to such questions, telcos must first gain a clear view of what’s driving asset-right strategies and what outcomes they’re looking to achieve. In terms of enablers, the key elements to take into account include supply-and-demand factors such as policy and regulatory evolution and anticipated retail and wholesale demand; the availability of potential strategic partners across the industry, as well as financial and public sectors investors; and the wide range of transaction structures and monetization options in the table, from outsourcing to partnership, and from JV to spin-off, sale-and-leaseback – all with their own timing and interplay considerations.

Commercial terms are also key, especially with arrangements such as sale-and-leaseback – including clauses such as exclusivity periods and anchor tenant commitments. Last but not least, asset-right can tie into organizational and process redesign, such as new information sharing mechanisms or the separation or retirement of IT systems. These issues may come more into play in datacenter deals.

With these levers fully understood and coordinated, what benefits can operators plan to get out of their asset-right strategy? These range from relatively simple outcomes such as debt reduction to more far-reaching ones such as increased management focus on innovation. Overall, we would highlight five benefits in particular:

  • Revenue opportunities: freeing up more management focus on new customer needs and offerings
  • Innovation: leveraging collaboration and greater management focus to develop new products and improve time to market
  • Complexity reduction: reducing operational complexity and increasing strategic predictability
  • Cash and margins: improving earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization (EBITDA) margins
  • Asset leverage: driving higher returns on capital employed (ROCE)

Time to revisit your strategy – and keep revisiting it

Given the industry landscape we’ve mapped out, we think revisiting their asset strategies isn’t an option for telcos. It’s a commercial and strategic imperative – and one that they should pursue as a matter of urgency, before others steal a march on them by snapping up the best opportunities.

To get in position for this rethink, an operator needs to gain a holistic view of the ecosystem and options, understand the dependencies, and take a measured and methodical approach to reshaping its asset portfolio. But this isn’t a one-off fix. So operators have no room to relax – but instead must remain more alive than ever to the changes coming down the line in the years up to 2025.

Together, these changes will make asset-right strategies even more pivotal to success. And as Figure 3 shows, the three key dimensions of change will be:

  • A more volatile operating environment: including fast-changing market conditions, shifting regulatory obligations (including around the digital divide), and competitors in one part of the value chain becoming collaborators or co-investors in another. Given the potential interdependencies, how will you strike the right balance between different asset approaches across your business?
  • New technology cycles and supply chains: concepts such as private and municipal networks are complementing traditional wide-area deployment models, and fixed-mobile convergence is evolving in new ways. Is your asset strategy granular enough to accommodate emerging business models and attuned to capitalizing on technology cycles?
  • Changing enterprise transformation needs: while going asset-right is important across multiple domains, so is the need for investment in key areas of the business – from organizational redesign to network functions virtualization to skills. How will your asset-right strategy dovetail with your organization’s broader transformation?
Infographic Asset right strategies: Factors and drive's on the road 2025

These questions and more will need to be addressed along the way. But as telcos look to reshape and reposition for success in the most complex and volatile environment they’ve ever faced, the message is clear: asset-right is the way to go. And the time to start? Today.

Summary

As telcos embark on a new wave of infrastructure rollout and service innovation, optimal infrastructure ownership positions are essential. By adopting asset-right strategies, operators can unlock capital, reduce business complexity, and improve management’s focus on value creation. Looking ahead, there are opportunities to revisit what is core and non-core right across the business, leveraging a range of options to ensure the best long-term outcomes.

About this article

Authors
Tom Loozen

EY Global Telecommunications Leader

Fascinated by the positive impact of telecoms. Passionate musician. Enjoys educating himself on psychology, wine, sports, technology, arts and much more. Husband and father of three daughters.

Adrian Baschnonga

EY Global Technology, Media & Entertainment and Telecommunications (TMT) Lead Analyst

Passionate about digital innovation and inclusion. Inspired by the arts, history and urban spaces.

Barak Ravid

EY-Parthenon Americas Leader

Energized by all things at the intersection of technology and strategy. Passionate about the strength of diverse and inclusive teams. Love sailing, biking, soccer, snowboarding. Father of three girls.

Ulrich Loewer

EY-Parthenon Partner, Technology, Media and Entertainment, and Telecommunications, Ernst & Young LLP

Thought leader in the TMT and Digital Infrastructure sector. Passionate about ubiquitous gigabit connectivity. Trusted for honest and inspiring advice. Proud father of Max and Mia.

Related topics TMT